A11yScan vs Silktide
Compare A11yScan with Silktide to choose the right accessibility testing platform for your organization.
The Verdict
Both A11yScan and Silktide are legitimate accessibility testing platforms that identify real code issues. Silktide offers a comprehensive platform with 200+ checks, PDF testing, and additional quality features. A11yScan provides focused, axe-core powered accessibility testing with free single-page scans. For organizations needing comprehensive web quality management with budget for premium tools, Silktide is strong. For straightforward accessibility testing, A11yScan is simpler and more accessible.
Silktide Web Accessibility Platform Overview
Silktide is a web accessibility and quality assurance platform that tests for over 200 WCAG checks, with additional modules for content, SEO, and performance. They use proprietary technology that simulates real browsers to test pages. A11yScan is a focused accessibility testing tool powered by axe-core. Both are legitimate testing tools that identify actual code issues rather than relying on overlay fixes.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | A11yScan | Silktide |
|---|---|---|
| Core Features | ||
| Automated WCAG Testing | 200+ checks | |
| Testing Engine | axe-core | Proprietary |
| Free Single Page Scan | ||
| Standards | ||
| WCAG 2.2 Support | ||
| Testing | ||
| Mobile Accessibility | WCAG 2.1 mobile | |
| Browser Simulation | Real browser rendering | |
| Reporting | ||
| Visual Issue Overlays | In-page overlays | |
| Documents | ||
| PDF Testing | ||
| Additional Features | ||
| Content Quality | Spelling, grammar | |
| SEO Testing | ||
| Tools | ||
| Chrome Extension | Free extension | |
| Services | ||
| Manual Audit Services | Available | Available |
| Support | ||
| Remediation Guidance | ||
Why Choose A11yScan
Free single-page accessibility scan
Powered by axe-core (industry standard)
Simple, focused interface
Clear remediation guidance
No contract required for basic use
Manual audit services available
Silktide Strengths
200+ WCAG accessibility checks
Real browser simulation testing
Visual in-page issue overlays
Combined accessibility, content, SEO
PDF accessibility testing
Mobile accessibility testing
Strong government/education presence
Consultancy and training services
Silktide Limitations
Custom pricing (not transparent)
12-month minimum contracts
No free scanning option
Premium pricing tier
May be more than needed for basic testing
Pricing Comparison
A11yScan Pricing
Free single-page scan; paid manual audits available
Silktide Pricing
Custom pricing based on site size; 12-month minimum contracts typical
Our Take
Silktide is a premium platform with custom pricing. A11yScan offers free single-page scans and straightforward manual audit pricing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does Silktide's testing compare to axe-core?
Silktide uses proprietary technology with 200+ WCAG checks and real browser simulation. A11yScan uses axe-core, the industry-standard open-source engine. Both identify legitimate accessibility issues. Using multiple tools can provide broader coverage.
Is Silktide an overlay tool?
No, Silktide is a testing tool, not an overlay widget. They identify issues in your code for you to fix, which is the correct approach. They're similar to A11yScan in philosophy - testing rather than overlaying.
Which is better for government or education?
Silktide has strong presence in government and education sectors. However, A11yScan's axe-core engine is also widely used in public sector accessibility testing. Both meet WCAG testing requirements.
Is Silktide's Chrome extension useful?
Silktide offers a free Chrome extension for quick accessibility checks. A11yScan offers free single-page scans through the web interface. Both are useful for quick testing before committing to a platform.
Other Comparisons
A11yScan vs WAVE
Compare A11yScan with WAVE to find the best web accessibility testing tool for your organization.
A11yScan vs axe
Compare A11yScan with axe DevTools to choose the right accessibility testing solution for your team.
A11yScan vs Lighthouse
Compare A11yScan with Google Lighthouse to understand which accessibility testing approach fits your needs.
A11yScan vs Siteimprove
Compare A11yScan with Siteimprove to choose the right enterprise accessibility platform for your organization.
A11yScan vs Tenon
Compare A11yScan with Tenon.io to choose the right accessibility testing API for your development workflow.
A11yScan vs Deque
Compare A11yScan with Deque Systems' accessibility solutions to find the right fit for your organization.
A11yScan vs AccessiBe
Compare A11yScan accessibility testing with AccessiBe's overlay widget to understand the fundamental differences in approach to web accessibility.
A11yScan vs UserWay
Compare A11yScan's accessibility testing approach with UserWay's accessibility widget to understand which solution fits your compliance needs.
A11yScan vs AudioEye
Compare A11yScan with AudioEye to understand the differences between these accessibility testing approaches.
A11yScan vs EqualWeb
Compare A11yScan's accessibility testing approach with EqualWeb's accessibility widget to choose the right solution for your compliance needs.
A11yScan vs accessibilityChecker.org
Compare A11yScan with AccessibilityChecker.org to choose the right accessibility testing tool for your needs.
A11yScan vs Pope Tech
Compare A11yScan with Pope Tech to choose the right accessibility testing platform for your organization.
A11yScan vs Monsido
Compare A11yScan with Monsido to choose the right accessibility platform for your organization's needs.
Ready to Try A11yScan?
Start with a free accessibility scan and see why teams choose A11yScan over Silktide.