A11yScan vs AudioEye
Compare A11yScan with AudioEye to understand the differences between these accessibility testing approaches.
The Verdict
AudioEye offers a comprehensive enterprise platform with both automated testing and expert services. However, their automated fix approach shares some concerns with overlay tools. A11yScan provides straightforward accessibility testing with clear remediation guidance. For organizations wanting simple, honest accessibility testing, A11yScan's approach is more transparent. For enterprises needing full-service accessibility management with budget for premium services, AudioEye may be appropriate.
AudioEye Accessibility Platform Overview
AudioEye is a digital accessibility platform that combines automated testing, automated fixes, and expert services. They claim to automatically fix up to 50% of detected issues and offer expert remediation for others. A11yScan is a testing tool powered by axe-core that identifies accessibility issues and provides remediation guidance. While AudioEye offers a more comprehensive (and expensive) platform, their automated fix approach has faced criticism similar to overlay tools.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | A11yScan | AudioEye |
|---|---|---|
| Testing | ||
| Automated WCAG Testing | ||
| axe-core Engine | ||
| Remediation | ||
| Automated Issue Fixes | Up to 50% of issues | |
| Services | ||
| Expert Code Fixes | Manual audits available | Custom code fixes |
| Document Remediation | PDF services available | |
| Monitoring | ||
| 24/7 Monitoring | ||
| User Features | ||
| User Toolbar | ||
| Legal | ||
| Legal Protection | Limited warranty | |
| Pricing | ||
| Free Single Page Scan | ||
| Standards | ||
| WCAG 2.1 Testing | 32 criteria automated | |
| Support | ||
| Remediation Guidance | Detailed guidance | Automated + expert |
Why Choose A11yScan
Free single-page accessibility scan
Powered by axe-core testing engine
Simple, straightforward pricing
Clear remediation guidance
No reliance on automated overlay fixes
Manual audit services available
AudioEye Strengths
Comprehensive enterprise platform
Expert services for complex issues
24/7 monitoring capabilities
Document remediation services
Large enterprise client base
Acquired multiple accessibility companies
AudioEye Limitations
Enterprise pricing not transparent
Automated fix approach is controversial
Previously sued accessibility expert (case dropped)
Automated fixes share overlay concerns
Complex platform may be overkill for many sites
Pricing Comparison
A11yScan Pricing
Free single-page scan; paid manual audits available
AudioEye Pricing
Enterprise pricing; contact sales for quotes. Has acquired multiple companies and offers various service tiers.
Our Take
AudioEye is an enterprise platform with comprehensive services and enterprise pricing. A11yScan offers free single-page scans and straightforward manual audit pricing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How is AudioEye different from overlay tools?
AudioEye offers more than just an overlay - they provide automated testing, expert services, and document remediation. However, their automated fix features operate similarly to overlays and face similar criticisms from accessibility experts.
Does AudioEye guarantee ADA compliance?
AudioEye offers limited legal warranty but cannot guarantee compliance. Their automated testing covers 32 WCAG criteria, but WCAG has 50+ success criteria, many requiring manual testing. No automated tool can ensure full compliance.
Is A11yScan as comprehensive as AudioEye?
AudioEye offers more services including 24/7 monitoring, document remediation, and expert fixes. A11yScan is a focused testing tool with manual audit services. If you need enterprise services, AudioEye offers more. If you want straightforward testing with clear guidance, A11yScan is simpler and more affordable.
Why did AudioEye sue an accessibility expert?
AudioEye previously filed a lawsuit against accessibility expert Adrian Roselli, which was dropped in January 2024. This followed criticism of automated accessibility approaches. Such lawsuits against critics have been controversial in the accessibility community.
Other Comparisons
A11yScan vs WAVE
Compare A11yScan with WAVE to find the best web accessibility testing tool for your organization.
A11yScan vs axe
Compare A11yScan with axe DevTools to choose the right accessibility testing solution for your team.
A11yScan vs Lighthouse
Compare A11yScan with Google Lighthouse to understand which accessibility testing approach fits your needs.
A11yScan vs Siteimprove
Compare A11yScan with Siteimprove to choose the right enterprise accessibility platform for your organization.
A11yScan vs Tenon
Compare A11yScan with Tenon.io to choose the right accessibility testing API for your development workflow.
A11yScan vs Deque
Compare A11yScan with Deque Systems' accessibility solutions to find the right fit for your organization.
A11yScan vs AccessiBe
Compare A11yScan accessibility testing with AccessiBe's overlay widget to understand the fundamental differences in approach to web accessibility.
A11yScan vs UserWay
Compare A11yScan's accessibility testing approach with UserWay's accessibility widget to understand which solution fits your compliance needs.
A11yScan vs EqualWeb
Compare A11yScan's accessibility testing approach with EqualWeb's accessibility widget to choose the right solution for your compliance needs.
A11yScan vs accessibilityChecker.org
Compare A11yScan with AccessibilityChecker.org to choose the right accessibility testing tool for your needs.
A11yScan vs Pope Tech
Compare A11yScan with Pope Tech to choose the right accessibility testing platform for your organization.
A11yScan vs Monsido
Compare A11yScan with Monsido to choose the right accessibility platform for your organization's needs.
A11yScan vs Silktide
Compare A11yScan with Silktide to choose the right accessibility testing platform for your organization.
Ready to Try A11yScan?
Start with a free accessibility scan and see why teams choose A11yScan over AudioEye.